Rapport

Report: Governing with the Living World

Report: Governing with the Living World

An overview of best governance practices that incorporate the voice of Nature and Future Generations in Europe.

An overview of best governance practices that incorporate the voice of Nature and Future Generations in Europe.

A European first in understanding the rise of ‘Nature on the Board’

A European first in understanding the rise of ‘Nature on the Board’

A European first in understanding the rise of ‘Nature on the Board’

‘Governing with Nature’ is the most comprehensive study published to date on 39 European organisations that have appointed one or more nature representatives to their governance structures.

Combining statistics, case studies, interviews and recommendations, this report provides decision-makers with the tools to build governance structures that ensure the long-term sustainability of their organisations.

With contributions from experts at organisations such as the University of Oxford, the UN Global Compact – France Network, and the Potsdam Institute for Climate Impact Research (PIK).

"Modern political and economic systems have built governance on an illusion: that human decisions can exist separate from planetary limits.

The European initiatives documented in this report by Vivoices demonstrate an essential awakening: that the circle of decision-making must expand."


Hindou Oumarou Ibrahim
Co-Chair of the International Indigenous Peoples Forum on Climate Change (IIPFCC)

"Modern political and economic systems have built governance on an illusion: that human decisions can exist separate from planetary limits.

The European initiatives documented in this report by Vivoices demonstrate an essential awakening: that the circle of decision-making must expand."


Hindou Oumarou Ibrahim
Co-Chair of the International Indigenous Peoples Forum on Climate Change (IIPFCC)

« Les systèmes politiques et économiques modernes ont fondé la gouvernance sur une illusion : celle que les décisions humaines pourraient exister indépendamment des limites planétaires.

Les initiatives européennes documentées par Vivøices dans ce rapport témoignent d’un éveil essentiel : le cercle de la décision doit s’élargir. »

Hindou Oumarou Ibrahim
Coprésidente du Forum international des peuples
autochtones sur les changements climatiques (IIPFCC)

Contents

An overview of nature governance in Europe

The report is divided into six chapters, providing a comprehensive overview of best governance practices that give a voice to the living world.

Scientists, CSR experts, campaigners: who is qualified to speak on behalf of nature?

Scientifiques, experts RSE, militants : qui est légitime pour parler au nom de la nature ?

Scientifiques, experts RSE, militants : qui est légitime pour parler au nom de la nature ?

The report

Giving nature a voice in governance is no longer an isolated experiment. Our survey brings together 39 organisations, representing around 75 per cent of the cases identified in Europe.

The majority of them (63 per cent) base their definition of nature on science, particularly planetary boundaries.

When selecting their representative, 67 per cent rely on their network, whilst only 18 per cent issue a public call for applications.

More than half (56 per cent) grant nature genuine decision-making power, with the right to vote or veto. However, only 13 per cent involve nature in the selection of their leaders.

Giving nature a voice in governance is no longer an isolated experiment. Our survey brings together 39 organisations, representing around 75 per cent of the cases identified in Europe.

The majority of them (63 per cent) base their definition of nature on science, particularly planetary boundaries.

When selecting their representative, 67 per cent rely on their network, whilst only 18 per cent issue a public call for applications.

More than half (56 per cent) grant nature genuine decision-making power, with the right to vote or veto. However, only 13 per cent involve nature in the selection of their leaders.

“The key to this transformation lies in integrating these systemic issues into governance, whether that be global economic governance, national regulation or corporate governance.

It means equipping ourselves with the means to anticipate risks and align strategies, funding mechanisms and impact measurement.”


Nils Pedersen
Executive Director at UN Global Compact France

« Les systèmes politiques et économiques modernes ont fondé la gouvernance sur une illusion : celle que les décisions humaines pourraient exister indépendamment des limites planétaires.

Les initiatives européennes documentées par Vivøices dans ce rapport témoignent d’un éveil essentiel : le cercle de la décision doit s’élargir. »

Hindou Oumarou Ibrahim
Coprésidente du Forum international des peuples
autochtones sur les changements climatiques (IIPFCC)

“The key to this transformation lies in integrating these systemic issues into governance, whether that be global economic governance, national regulation or corporate governance.

It means equipping ourselves with the means to anticipate risks and align strategies, funding mechanisms and impact measurement.”


Nils Pedersen
Executive Director at UN Global Compact France

Case studies

Des cas d'étude de pionniers et entretiens avec les représentant.e.s de la nature

Several case studies are presented alongside interviews with representatives of Nature. At Riversimple (Wales), one of Europe’s pioneering models, the environment sits as a voting member amongst the ‘guardians’ on the board of directors. norsys (France) goes a step further: Nature sits on the board of directors and at the shareholders’ meeting, with voting and veto rights. Northern Playground (Norway) shares details of its pilot scheme for a Nature representative.

Faith in Nature (United Kingdom) has appointed a Nature guardian who votes on all matters and is involved in the approval of new products. House of Hackney (United Kingdom) has a director who represents Nature and future generations.

The Tilt Movement (France) has created a seat for Nature on its board of directors to give a voice to living beings. Maison Dandoy (Belgium), a family-run biscuit manufacturer founded in 1829, has appointed a Nature guardian to its strategic committee.

Testimonies

We interviewed leaders who shared their experiences of the impact of integrating nature into their governance. You can read their accounts in the report.

This approach to governance has deepened our understanding of how closely connected we are to the Natural world, and how much our business depends on its health and resilience. Our Nature Guardian helps us look ahead to the inevitable effects of climate change on our planet and understand how these might affect our supply chains and the ingredients available to us. Her contribution also shapes how we train and empower our people, helping to bring Nature into everyday thinking and decision-making across the business. In turn, this openness about our relationship with Nature has helped build greater transparency and trust with our customers.

LFLaura Ford
Laura Ford
Sustainability Director, Faith In Nature

This approach to governance has deepened our understanding of how closely connected we are to the Natural world, and how much our business depends on its health and resilience. Our Nature Guardian helps us look ahead to the inevitable effects of climate change on our planet and understand how these might affect our supply chains and the ingredients available to us. Her contribution also shapes how we train and empower our people, helping to bring Nature into everyday thinking and decision-making across the business. In turn, this openness about our relationship with Nature has helped build greater transparency and trust with our customers.

LFLaura Ford
Laura Ford
Sustainability Director, Faith In Nature

“Cette approche de la gouvernance nous a permis de mieux comprendre à quel point nous sommes étroitement liés au monde naturel, et combien notre entreprise dépend de sa santé et de sa résilience. Notre Gardienne de la Nature nous aide à anticiper les effets inévitables du changement climatique sur notre planète et à comprendre comment ils pourraient affecter nos chaînes d’approvisionnement et les ingrédients dont nous disposons. En retour, cette transparence sur notre relation à la Nature a renforcé la confiance de nos clients.”

Laura Ford

Directrice durabilité, Faith In Nature

“Donner une place à la Nature et aux générations futures dans notre gouvernance a changé la question que nous posons avant un arbitrage : au-delà du coût ou du rendement immédiat, quel impact nos choix auront-ils sur nos équipes, nos producteurs, les écosystèmes, le vivant et la pérennité de la Maison ? Cette boussole nous pousse à rechercher une création de valeur plus durable et mieux partagée.”

Antoine Helson

Co-fondateur, Maison Dandoy

“Chez norsys, nous appréhendons la nature sous l’angle des limites planétaires. Pour donner corps à cette approche, nous avons travaillé avec le Stockholm Resilience Centre, ce qui a permis de mieux comprendre les impacts et dépendances de notre activité et de notre chaîne de valeur sur ces limites planétaires.”

Thomas Breuzard

Actionnaire et directeur permaentreprise, Groupe norsys

“Nous nous appuyons essentiellement sur notre réseau. Nous sommes très sensibles aux personnes que nous croisons sur notre chemin, à leur regard sur notre métier et à leur compréhension de nos enjeux.”

Morgane le Breton

Co-gérante de la Maison Lebreton

“Ma présence a surtout permis de rendre les discussions concrètes. J’ai insisté pour que mes interlocuteurs perçoivent l’importance des interactions dans les forêts. Ce n’est pas seulement une question de stocks ou d’espèces, c’est une question de relations.”

Benjamin Allegrini

Représentant de la nature au comité de mission, Groupe Bayard

“En sus de mettre les limites planétaires au sein des boards de nos participations, nous les mettons au cœur des instances de gouvernance du fonds, notamment au board qui réunit les investisseurs. Nous garantissons leur prise en compte dans toutes les décisions.”

Audrey Lambry

Directrice durabilité et impact, Eurazeo

“Nous avons conçu et déployé, dans plusieurs entreprises belges, des comités de régénération incluant systématiquement des représentants de la nature et des limites planétaires. Ces comités jouent un rôle de questionnement, de conseil et d’influence auprès des dirigeants et administrateurs.”

Vincent Truyens

Fondateur, Corporate ReGeneration

“Mon rôle au sein du board du Fonds 2050 consiste surtout à faire prendre conscience de l’absence de nature dans un monde marqué par l’artificialité. Il s’agit moins de transformer la décision que de questionner les conditions de cette décision.”

Sénamé Koffi

Porte-parole de la nature, Fonds 2050

“Avoir Mère Nature au conseil a donné à chacun la permission d’apporter sa raison d’être au travail. Nous sommes tous nature, humains compris. Chez House of Hackney, nous pensons à 1 000 ans quand nous planifions ce que nous faisons aujourd’hui.”

Javvy M. Royle

Cofondateur, House of Hackney

“Parmi nos objectifs statutaires, les deux derniers ciblent la contribution à la transition écologique et la promotion du développement de modèles d’entreprises engagées dans la recherche d’impacts positifs.”

Franck Carnero

Directeur Mission et Impact, MAIF

A study involving a wide range of organisations

A study involving a wide range of organisations

This report brings together contributions from Oxford University · Sciences Po Paris · the University of Fribourg · the Potsdam Institute for Climate Impact Research (PIK) · the UN Global Compact – France Network · the Economic, Social and Environmental Council (CESE) · the Circle of Jurists on the Rights of Nature (CJDN) · Shareholders for Climate (APC).

With the support of communities and specialist organisations such as B Lab Europe · the Mission-Driven Business Community · the Earth Law Centre · Corporate ReGeneration.

Thank you to all of them for their participation, and to all the companies, foundations and associations that took part in the study.

This report brings together contributions from Oxford University · Sciences Po Paris · the University of Fribourg · the Potsdam Institute for Climate Impact Research (PIK) · the UN Global Compact – France Network · the Economic, Social and Environmental Council (CESE) · the Circle of Jurists on the Rights of Nature (CJDN) · Shareholders for Climate (APC).

With the support of communities and specialist organisations such as B Lab Europe · the Mission-Driven Business Community · the Earth Law Centre · Corporate ReGeneration.

Thank you to all of them for their participation, and to all the companies, foundations and associations that took part in the study.

Experts

The experts who contributed to the report

We would like to thank everyone who contributed to this major study.

We would like to thank everyone who contributed to this major study.

Presentation of the study and strategic seminars

Présentation de l'étude et
séminaires stratégiques

Presentation of the study and strategic seminars

The Vivøices team organises seminars, conferences and workshops to help businesses, foundations and organisations better understand and incorporate nature and future generations into their governance.

Please contact us for further information.

The Vivøices team organises seminars, conferences and workshops to help businesses, foundations and organisations better understand and incorporate nature and future generations into their governance.

Please contact us for further information.